Tampilkan postingan dengan label music. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label music. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 29 April 2011

KIM VII -- chapter 4.1: A Second Son at Least!

"On the Road"
stop reading at: "He was nearly asleep when the lama suddenly quoted a proverb: 'The husbands of the talkative have a great reward hereafter.' Then Kim heard him snuff thrice, and dozed off, still laughing."
  1. age-old question: The Lama's situation reminds me of a theme from the Agent Pendergast novel (Lincoln/Child) I just finished reading.  Sometimes ignorance truly is bliss, inasmuch as the truth--or the process of gaining it--is so potentially painful.  Is the Lama better off in the dark regarding, or ignorant of, the "real world" (he wonders whether Kim is a spirit or an evil imp) or to see it, experience it, and gain wisdom?  Is Kim better off as he is (he is, after all, an exceedingly happy and optimistic individual), or were he more like the Lama?  More broadly, I think about my children: is it better to protect them from the world that perhaps they may be happier for the lack of darkness thereof, or better off experiencing/observing as much of it as possible?
  2. Along the same lines, Kim, particularly considering his so-terrene nickname, is worldly, while the Lama seeks apparently to avoid worldliness.  The word (and its derivations), "worldly," is pretty plastic in its application.  In its most obvious, Kim is in "the seventh heaven of happiness" as he passes along the Old Trunk Road, watching the world pass by below him, while the Lama keeps, essentially, his eyes and mind closed to all but his own meditations.  Any thoughts here?
  3. The long descriptive paragraphs in the first few pages of this chapter are gorgeous--not necessarily in their prose, but in their subject and the details of which Kipling chooses to accent: a riot of color, life, creatures--animal and humans alike (and how appropriately so!) --sin and piety, caste and race.  What is your impression of life around the Old Trunk Road?
  4. (Is it just me, or is there a taste of Dickens about this book: the orphan, the bustling city...?)
  5. I'm interested in the tonal arc of this chapter and how the ambient activity and light/dark reflect in the mood of the day's inhabitants.


Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones

Selasa, 22 Maret 2011

The Mysterious Flame of Queen Loana IX -- chapter 8: PULP FICTION and other POP FROM THE PAST

  1. "Are you clear about the distance between you and these stories?"  Is this a valid question, despite Yambo's argument that he's not crazy?  On the other side of the equation, how might recounting the stories as he is to children and grandchildren be perhaps a better way to spark the flame than simply rereading them alone in the attic?
  2. Why might pulp literature--or even Stevenson--be a better vehicle for the spark and flame than "Homer, Manzoni, and Flaubert"?
  3. "Radio, the voice that enchants"; "enchants," being, of course, the operative word.
  4. Tabula rasa is a Locke coinage, as far as I know.  Certainly Yambo's slate has been razed, but is it true that by listening to his friend it's being spoiled by/with another's memories?
  5. "Over the previous few days, I had been trying to imagine the divided self of a boy exposed to messages of national glory while at the same time daydreaming about the fogs of London, where he would encounter Fantômas battling Sandokan amid a hail of nailshot that ripped holes in the chests and tore off the arms and legs of Sherlock Holmes’s politely perplexed compatriots—and now here I was learning that in those same years the radio had been proposing as an ideal the life of a humble accountant who longed for nothing more than suburban tranquility" (emphasis added).  Yambo seems to worry his way through this and subsequent paragraphs that all the varied media stimuli might have incited moral contradiction and confusion in his past self (though, interestingly, he seem to be observing or discovering his own past in the third person, but not necessarily as the past but as if it were presently happening).  Is the massive exposure to media such a problem as Yambo imagines it to be?  Why might he be worried about it at all, as that boy from the past is him, and, well, hasn't he turned out all right--except for this whole amnesia thing, of course?
  6. So why is it so vital that he find his old schoolbooks?
  7. The woman ("like a saxophone in heat" ... uh, whoa!) in the lyric recalls a bit the women of the cocoa and antacid tins from the previous chapter.  Obviously women play/ed a big role in Yambo's life, but what, by evidence here and elsewhere, do you supposed that role really is?

Sabtu, 05 Maret 2011

East of Eden BONUS -- Mumford and Sons: "TIMSHEL"

I am new to Mumford and Sons.  I have an old friend to thank for posting this on FB.  I put it here for it's poignant pertinence to the book, East of Eden.  Thanks, Allen.

Kamis, 03 Maret 2011

GENRE FICTION: KEELER versus PATTERSON by analogy of METAL

While I tend to avoid for the most part the "lesser" writing of so-called genre-fiction (becoming less and less the case as I continue to find, or am introduced to, examples of the stuff of unimpeachable literary excellence), I have always harbored a taste, and kept it fairly closeted until now, for another strain of genre, this one "musical" (quotes should connote potential for sarcasm) --that of heavy metal.  Just like mystery and sci-fi and thriller and horror and whatever else in fiction, so in music there is hip-hop, R&B, grunge, metal, jazz, and so on--ad infinitum, really (just check out that family tree of rock n' roll below).

a graphical history of 40 years' of rock n' roll, from lindsargwatt.com

I have not been quiet about my recent reading of Harry Stephen Keeler's mystery novel, Riddle of the Traveling Skull, which both delighted and astonished me.  I am now reading another genre piece, this one by famed genre master ("genre": though not typical of this author; and "master" only if sheer staggering quantity of book sales qualifies one for such a title), James Patterson: his Witch and Wizard (well, it's not really his--some Charbonet character, ghost writer--but has his name on the cover and bigger, which is essentially the same thing, as I can't imagine he'd sign off on it if it didn't at least match his far-from stringent qualifications).  While I firmly believe that Keeler surpassed the typecast of his genre (and this by a dense combination of wit, originality, utter abandonment of reality, and a total dedication to his craft), Patterson has murdered it.

Let's keep things as positive as possible, however, at least for a minute, if no more, because, well, Patterson must be doing something right if he's got 200 million books sold, right?  W&W is written for teens.  Teens have a short attention span (if this sounds like an insult, it's meant to; I don't feel this way about adolescents, but clearly Patterson does).  So instead of bogging down the reader with things like exposition and description and even emotion, Patterson simply deletes them.  Sure, the more seasoned reader is left with the impression that he's reading a plot summary or liner notes under the panels of storyboard illustrations for in-development B-movie, but teens are eating it up.  And, well, it could even be seen as a good introduction to fantasy for new readers, especially because there's absolutely nothing original to it. The book flagrantly steals most obviously and glaringly from The Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter, among many others, including Lev Grossman's The Magicians (any of which is a little like watching some hack in the audition rounds of American Idol attempt a Whitney Houston number--why would he even want to have his book compared to theirs???).

Now, I've never read anything else by Patterson, so take my snap judgments of him with a grain of salt, and I don't plan to, especially after this.  I picked up W&W because so many of my students are reading it, and I wanted to be able to talk to them about it.  That and it was only 6 bucks at Wal-Mart, and I needed a new book for the bathroom.  Perhaps my problem here--because, really, this book is not next door to terrible, but flagrantly squatting in Terrible's moldy boiler room--is that maybe, just maybe, Patterson should have left fantasy alone and stuck with his more practiced genres of thriller and mystery, not to mention his shift of target audience (which audience, teen/young adult, and which genre, fantasy, tend toward the realms of sacred for me, especially in the case of the audience he's infiltrating (maybe I'm just jealous!)).  To really get my point across, however, I think I need to paint all this in the vibrant tones of analogy.

When I was a teen, my favorite genre band--hard rock/metal (metal, of course, is a subjective term and has developed significantly over the last thirty years) --was Metallica: slightly more musical than others, certainly more popular, and particularly great for weight-room blasting after track practice.  Over the years, of course, I grew up, and slowly grew away from Metallica.  In 1999, however, genre buster and genius composer/conductor for the San Francisco Symphony, Michael Kamen, decided to do up a fat concert's-worth of Metallica charts for symphonic orchestra, and charter the band to take the stage right with the strings and brass, winds and percussion.

The result was absolutely tremendous, and I loved it.  If pulp mysteries may be perhaps aligned with metal, maybe specifically Metallica, then Harry Stephen Keeler is Michael Kamen: a little bit crazy, a little bit genius, a lot reckless, and totally given up to having fun with what he does best and loves.  No matter how crazy, it just freaking works.

James Patterson, on the other hand, and apart from genre shifting yet, is more like pop hard rockers Godsmack, who simply take all the ideas that everyone else has already had, inject it all with a little more sex, a little more violence, and lot more bad language, and sell it to the highest bidder: teenagers.  Now imagine, just for a minute and the sake of argument, that a band like Godsmack took something sacred, like, oh, I don't know, Debussy's "Claire de Lune" and translated it to their particular brand of metal?  Well, you'd get--  Hold on.  Let me repeat that fantasy has more potential for sublimity, I think, than any of the other "genres."  Disbelieve me?  Take a look at the greats: Lord of the Rings and Ender's Game, a couple of my most mainstream favorites, and Summerland, though it's less well-known, or the brilliant stuff that someone like Margaret Atwood or Lewis Carroll or Louis Lowry or, heck, even Douglas Adams (to name only a few of the dozens of this world's and our history's greats) can do with it.  Let's use Lord of the Rings.  It's about as obvious for it's brilliance as is Debussy's "Moonlight."  See what I'm getting at here?  "Claire de Lune" is to Godsmack as Lord of the Rings is to James Patterson.

When it comes right down to it, the idea behind W&W is actually pretty okay, but instead of giving it to Godsmack (because Patterson DID NOT WRITE IT), why not dish it off to a band that can actually play--like a Sevendust or a Tool or a Porcupine Tree (okay, not metal, but it would be awesome) or, yeah, even Metallica?  Better yet, why not a Michael Kamen and the brute, masterful force of his orchestra behind him?  Because I still like a lot of metal out there.  And sometimes, cross-genre translations do work, but I'm sorry: Mr. Patterson, Ms. Charbonnet, yours doesn't.

(Ugh.  I'm gonna go read a poem.)

Selasa, 18 Januari 2011

Jane Eyre XXIII -- chapter 23: LIGHTNING AND FIRE

  1. Bronte misquotes Thomas Campbell's poem, "The Turkish Lady."  Check line 5: HERE.
  2. The first page or two of chapter 23 can be described easily as Romantic--and not "romantic," as in the 'til-now stymied romance between Jane and Mr.R, but Romantic, as in the written gushing effulgence of emotion and unquenched idealism.
  3. So, first Romanticism and now Mr.R is pointing out this amazing moth, alien denizen of the night!, and I'm reminded of the albatross from Coleridge's "Rime of the Ancient Mariner."  (If you're going to bother with this question, don't read Coleridge's second master piece passively; this is a BIG and IMPORTANT work.)  I haven't read ahead and don't know if this moth turns out indeed to be a portent one way or another, but the at-least-partially-aligned imagery and tone are both here.  Notice also the mention of the sea foam and imminent voyage to Ireland.  
  4. When Jane complains about her necessary--and necessary by statement from Rochester--departure from Thornfield, what is she really complaining of?
  5. Is Jane a woman like Lot's wife?  Will she look back?  And what if she does not depart?  What might this indicate of Thornfield, if this is indeed an apt comparison?
  6. What's with the sudden usage of "Janet"?
  7. "I sometimes have a queer feeling with regard to you—especially when you are near me, as now: it is as if I had a string somewhere under my left ribs, tightly and inextricably knotted to a similar string situated in the corresponding quarter of your little frame. And if that boisterous channel, and two hundred miles or so of land come broad between us, I am afraid that cord of communion will be snapped; and then I've a nervous notion I should take to bleeding inwardly. As for you—you'd forget me."  Is Bronte referring to the taken rib from Adam to make Eve?  Is she referring, strangely, to the umbilical cord?  What is going on in this absolutely fascinating quotation?
  8. More poetry!  Considering the period of the book's composition together with the heavy Romanticism of the book and this particular chapter respectively, check out Keats' "Ode to a Nightingale" HERE, a truly masterful and hugely influential poem (at least as much so as "Mariner" above).
  9. I do love to see the fire of Jane's childhood reemerge here in conversation with Mr.R, but culminating in a kiss!?  What is the man trying to do to our poor girl?
  10. Name the many reasons Jane has to doubt Mr.R's sincerity of proposal.
  11. What of the change of weather and general tone shift at the point of Jane's acceptance?  Remember the weather at the beginning of the book when we spoke of Gothicism, especially as it conflicts with Romanticism.  There is a strikingly similar moment in The Sound of Music (today, apparently, is the day of comparative literature).
  12. What of the lightning-struck tree, so like a tower?  If this is indeed reference to Tarot, what of the shift from Tower to Tree?

Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones

Minggu, 02 Januari 2011

Sunday Poetry IX -- FROSTED BELLS for NEW YEAR'S

Usually I find back stories for things like this a drag, but today I'm doing it anyway, because the connection doesn't make any sense without the context.

Usually sometime Saturday night (especially now that church time has been moved up to nine), I start thinking about what I might do for Sunday Poetry.  Considering the time of year, both for earth's tilt and our current spot in the calendar, the weather--frigidly cold and snowy--and the New Year circled me mind.  Here in Utah right now, while not setting any records, it is frigidly cold.  The effect of this icy average is augmented by the general emotional impression left by what the recent cold snap's abrupt arrival did to the heavy slush fall from the day before followed by a dry powdery snow then a partial melt-off and finally another wicked freeze last night.

Walking across the church parking lot this morning was dangerous!

The coldest poem I know is "Out, Out -" by the late and way great Robert Frost (who, for some reason--and corroborated by appearances--resides on a particular shelf in my mind right next door to Cormac McArthy


)
(Do you know which one is which?)
Read this poem, and tell me it doesn't just make you shiver, shiver in horrific chill, sure, but as surely shiver in synesthetic frigidity (yes, synesthesia again: one of the greatest abilities of great writing):

The buzz saw snarled and rattled in the yard
And made dust and dropped stove-length sticks of wood,
Sweet-scented stuff when the breeze drew across it.
And from there those that lifted eyes could count
Five mountain ranges one behind the other
Under the sunset far into Vermont.
And the saw snarled and rattled, snarled and rattled,
As it ran light, or had to bear a load.
And nothing happened: day was all but done.
Call it a day, I wish they might have said
To please the boy by giving him the half hour
That a boy counts so much when saved from work.
His sister stood beside him in her apron
To tell them "Supper." At the word, the saw,
As if it meant to prove saws know what supper meant,
Leaped out at the boy's hand, or seemed to leap -
He must have given the hand. However it was,
Neither refused the meeting. But the hand!
Half in appeal, but half as if to keep
The life from spilling. Then the boy saw all -
Since he was old enough to know, big boy
Doing a man's work, though a child at heart -
He saw all was spoiled. "Don't let him cut my hand off -
The doctor, when he comes. Don't let him, sister!"
So. The hand was gone already.
The doctor put him in the dark of ether.
He lay and puffed his lips out with his breath.
And then - the watcher at his pulse took a fright.
No one believed. They listened to his heart.
Little - less - nothing! - and that ended it.
No more to build on there. And they, since they
Were not the one dead, turned to their affairs.

Okay, so for the season that seems really negative, and, well, I guess it is.  *not a non-sequitur:*  If you read this blog and have at least followed the Sunday Poetry entries, you should remember last week's interesting parallel between two pieces by Poe--the story, "The Black Cat," and the poem, "The Bells."  Well, this week's pair of pieces are not parallel; I believe they're perpendicular.  "Out, Out -" doesn't seem in any way to celebrate the birth of the new year, at least inasmuch as the holiday is indeed about rebirth and the New and all that mushy stuff.  But remember, as one year is born, so one dies, and should we not walk away from it perhaps even without looking back over our shoulder?

Anyway, I don't know how the connection was made--what or which synaptic firing caught this other one in the cross--but next I thought of Alfred, Lord Tennyson's "Ring Out, Wild Bells," which is all about the temporal crux of New Year's:


Ring out, wild bells, to the wild sky,
The flying cloud, the frosty light;
The year is dying in the night;
Ring out, wild bells, and let him die.

Ring out the old, ring in the new,
Ring, happy bells, across the snow:
The year is going, let him go;
Ring out the false, ring in the true.

Ring out the grief that saps the mind,
For those that here we see no more,
Ring out the feud of rich and poor,
Ring in redress to all mankind.

Ring out a slowly dying cause,
And ancient forms of party strife;
Ring in the nobler modes of life,
With sweeter manners, purer laws.

Ring out the want, the care, the sin,
The faithless coldness of the times;
Ring out, ring out thy mournful rhymes,
But ring the fuller minstrel in.

Ring out false pride in place and blood,
The civic slander and the spite;
Ring in the love of truth and right,
Ring in the common love of good.

Ring out old shapes of foul disease,
Ring out the narrowing lust of gold;
Ring out the thousand wars of old,
Ring in the thousand years of peace.

Ring in the valiant man and free,
The larger heart, the kindlier hand;
Ring out the darkness of the land,
Ring in the Christ that is to be.

It's the ringing of the bells--the tonal tintinnabulation, that, while in Poe is a tocsin of doom, in Tynneson verily sparkles--that brings the warm fuzzies so associated with New Year's.  But look more closely: inasmuch as "The Bells" and "The Black Cat" --ostensibly so totally different--tell the same story and are quite parallel, so too are both of these poems, "Out, Out -" and "Ring Out, Wild Bells," converge at the same point: New Year's, though clearly from two different directions.

More interestingly still (at least for a great geek like me) is the haunting melody ascribed to the latter of the two, by Crawford Gates.  For me, artistically speaking rather than temporally, at least for the moment, this, by the meeting of tone and lyric, is where the two poems by Frost and Tennyson meet:




*

Minggu, 12 Desember 2010

Sunday Poetry IV -- My Collective Rambling Take on "The Collected Poetical Works of T.E. Hulme"

WARNING!  THIS ENTRY IS HUMONGOUS!

It's no surprise by now that I love Thomas Ernest Hulme.  In spite of this love, I have attempted to keep my commentary as unbiased and broad as possible; and, as in my classroom teaching (not that any of you really require a teacher), have tried merely to point out the available doors, opening only a few, rather than shove you through them.  I am, as always, entirely open to contradiction and refutation, discussion and question, and even, if you're willing, blind sycophancy.

***

I would like to offer two categories of the beautiful, and those based upon the artists who create, rather than the works themselves.  First, there are those artists whose raw, natural abilities permit them apparently effortless access to the beautiful.  Examples: Mozart and Chopin (see playlist below), Matsuo Basho, Carl Lewis and Usain Bolt (forgive the inclusion of athletics, but I do indeed see track and field as art, truly).  Second, there are artists whose talents they must wrestle and struggle into submission in order to most efficiently and effectively magnify them.  Examples: Bach and Debussy, Mike Powell and Michael Johnson, T.E. Hulme.  The former astound like the gods; the latter astound like only the most dedicated and successful of humanity can, whose tortuous and oft tortured hard work (and think Mike Powell, a long jumper, doesn’t fit the bill?  Read about him) play out in their art and genius so much more resonantly than that of one who just does it.  The art and success don’t flow from the soul like breath; rather they’re a mortal struggle, and only the strongest survive.


The Effortless (Usain Bolt; Carl Lewis):





The Dedicated (Michael Johnson; Mike Powell):


It’s possible that Hulme is not one who managed survival.  After all, what is the measuring stick for a poet’s success?  Depending upon your functioning definition of survival, at least in this context, consider this: T.S. Eliot (no poetry slouch, I’m sure you’ll agree) claimed in his The Criterion that Hulme had written “two or three of the most beautiful poems in the language.”  But If that's the case, and in consideration of "survival," here’s what I don’t get?  If this dude—Thomas Ernest Hulme—is really so freaking great, then why doesn’t anyone ever study him!?  Why didn't he write more? Why isn't he ever on a Hallmark card?  (Perhaps this should be the ambition of teacherly life.)

Thomas Ernest Hulme only ever published 7 poems.  (Any others we have were all published posthumously.)  While there are further poems of his available now, they’ve been culled from his personal notebooks or they were published not as stand-alone works but demonstrations for his literary philosophies.  5 of the aforementioned 7 were made available by Ezra Pound, as I’ve enthusiastically mentioned before.  The 6th of the 7 is more like this:


Even before reading the poem—all 8 words of it—the title alone, “Image,” tells us it doesn’t belong.  What kind of title is that?  Well, actually, as titles go, it fits the bill, making suggestion of, without giving away, the material to follow; but it’s so generic (especially compared to two other similar poems, which we’ll look at shortly, “In a Station of the Metro,” by Ezra Pound, and “The Red Wheelbarrow,” by William Carlos Williams) as to be glib.  (It is possible the title is in fact not a title at all, but a label ascribed by some anonymous editor somewhere along the line; I recently found the two lines in their original philosophical context and it, together with a companion piece (see way below), was without title of any sort.)  This poem was an experiment, yet an experiment profound enough to warrant inclusion to major literature anthologies and, less significantly, change my life.  Here they are, Hulme's third:

     In a Station of the Metro
     The apparition of these faces in the crowd;
     Petals on a wet, black bough.
     —Ezra Pound

     The Red Wheelbarrow
     so much depends
     upon

     a red wheel
     barrow

     glazed with rain
     water

     beside the white
     chickens.
     —William Carlos Williams

     Image
     Old houses were scaffolding once
     and workmen whistling.
     —T.E. Hulme

Hulme’s definition of the concept of IMAGE is this: just what the senses can acquire instantaneously via presented material.  That being the case, each of these poems is indeed imagistic—Pound’s is the most romantic, tapping directly into the emotion of a metro station, insinuating the weather and colors and thus the mood of the place; Williams’ is very localized, yet through its few words paints a picture of an entire farm, wet, green, and gray after a storm or shower; but it is Hulme’s that is the most expansive, reaching through the entire life of a house, an "old" house—one that has survived, either for its grace, its structural integrity, historical significance, or some combination thereof.  This image, more than just the house, calls also on the reader's impressions and experiences of City and the given city’s history and the surrounding buildings.  The poem took on greater significance for me when I lived in Saginaw, Michigan (as compared to having first encountered the poem in Provo, Utah), a once-great city losing its light by the plague of rotten economy, and perhaps more similar to what Hulme had in mind.  It is a city replete with blocks and blocks of old houses that were certainly once mere scaffolding and whistling workmen, then made homes with tended yards and family traffic, then subdivided for apartments, and now forgotten and moldering under dirt and ivy.

Yet this poem, beautiful as it is—or, rather, as beautiful as its image is (there is a difference  between the sign for something—here, the poem—and the referent—the image) —was not written for its own merit, but as demonstration for his definition of Image and what the potential of words may be to literally stimulate more than just eyes or ears.  There is something about the immediacy of “Image,” the poem, that brings me the smell of wet concrete, dug earth; the sound of distant construction workers’ talking and laughing and of their hammers and the creaking timbers raised in frames, then the emotional weight of the history that follows.  While this effect, for me anyway, is less with Pound’s attempt, Williams’ "The Red Wheelbarrow," on the other hand, similarly manages to prick the schema and recall a composite of all my many Midwest memories of rain and farm and all the subsequent sensory impressions right along with them.  Pound’s lack of success--more unfair than it deserves--for me is most likely due to my absence of personal history with metro, train, or subway stations.

While none of Hulme’s poetry can be reasonably labeled as “widely published” or “recognized,” there are 5 that are at least available with relatively little digging (in order of their appearance in Hulme’s Ripostes): “Mana Aboda,” “Autumn,” “Above the Dock,” The Embankment,” and “Conversion.”  Pound’s tribute was not the first publication for all these poems, but I think there’s a measure of his own artistic touch (particularly as "Autumn" was originally published before "Mana Aboda") in his order of their presentation.  This sequence is as tangible a contribution to the overall collection’s  substance as the poetry itself, and for this organization of assembly is potentially indicated Hulme’s overall philosophy, approach, and frustration (which emotion I’m less convinced was an issue, and may actually need to be replaced with boredom, as I’m learning*) with writing poetry.  The problem is that this impression may be solely evinced by the fabrication of Pound’s assemblage, not the words of his friend that fill the after-market scaffold.

***

The Collected Poetical Works of Thomas Ernest Hulme

Whatever may be the case and what may or may not have been communicated and manipulated between Pound and Hulme for the publication of the former’s book, the progression of idea and theme through the five poems is undeniable, and I mentally compare it to a ballet—the musical elements, at least, though the dancers are not uninvited.  Consider Andy Narrell’s Green Ballet.  The pieces are disparate, yet possess between them a similarity of concept, approach, and style which work together to, as they say, make the whole greater than the pieces.  Similarly, as Hulme’s work transcends the old limitations of words, so does Narrell (a humbler accomplishment, though nonetheless beautiful) transcend the old limitations of steel drums.

Before you go on, take a moment a reread the five poems, and while reading look for the following motifs and themes: beauty, mythology (and general religiosity, especially in terms of our proximity to heaven, where deity resides), and references to agriculture; as well as a general impression of whether the poem leans toward the positive connotation or the negative.

…

Conclusion?  If you were to label just one of the motifs or themes as the one most dominant, which would it be?  It would be beauty, as far as I’m concerned, and both in mention and demonstration and as it relates to God.  While its intention is vague in Ripostes (and specific only to “Mana Aboda” in its other published locations, T.E. Hulme, Selected Writings and The Collected Writings of T.E. Hulme), the prefatory sentence is significant, despite how hard it is to really "get."  I believe that Pound, if not Hulme, saw this sentence as a viable preface not just for “Mana Aboda,” but for all five poems together, and that he intended it to behave as such.  This being the case, then Beauty is definitely our dominant theme, especially considering the final poem, “Conversion,” which takes place “in the time of hyacinths,” a classic and mythical symbol for sublime beauty, and thus the opposing book end.

So what about the poems’ connoted moods?  Is beauty not an issue of the good and pleasant and happy?  On the scale from positive to negative—zero in the middle—doesn’t beauty fall, by its very nature, dominantly, if not wholly, on the plus side?

This preface, I think, is decidedly negative.  If beauty is a soldier (recalling Hulme’s military service), it merely marks time; if it’s among the realm of physics (recalling Hulme’s other dominant interest), then it makes no waves, ineffectual and impotent; if the next—a “feigned ecstasy of an arrested impulse” —well, then we need to broaden our gaze.

Remember Samuel Taylor Coleridge and his Romanticism, in particular that of “Kubla Kahn” —the very embodiment in textual form of the definition for Romanticism?  The Romantics were all about finding the explosive ecstasy of the creative process and painting it within the frame of literature.  Hulme mocks this.  (For my part, I love Coleridge, though not as much as Hulme, but if proof is in the pudding, Coleridge is the more durable.)  That ecstasy of surging poetic expression and experience—union of natural inspiration and poetical genius—is feigned!  It’s a farce!  It doesn’t really happen!  And it’s natural end, perhaps—a piece of poetry that adequately praises beauty and its eternal creator—isn’t realized.  Nor is it in Hulme's.

Why?

Well, that’s where we get to “Mana Aboda,” which contextualizes the prefatory statement and leads us into the following four.

I've talked a little about this one before.  What it comes down to is that Mana Aboda, a goddess (but more than that if you dig into here name: the celestial home or locus of godly power in feminine form), is bored with attempted poetic praise, yet, by indication of her hunching over the Earth and her mourning, appears intent on seeing what else might come her way.  Is she sad that something better hasn't come along, that the creations (her creations?) can't manage better than they do?  Interesting the Hulme chooses "Josephs" as the descriptor for all the poets, perhaps even himself.  Joseph, the stepfather to God's son on earth.  Poets will never be gods, but what of their poetry?  Is there more potential here, and that's why she mourns?  If poets may indeed be Josephs, can their poetry be sires of God?

"Autumn" departs this small religiosity and takes a more Tolkein'ish stance--bucolic and agrarian.  But God is not absent; He's never far from one of these five poems, in fact, as Hulme seems entirely bent on maintaining an upward gaze, except in "Conversion," later one.  But here, God, or the god, present as the face of the moon (and this is the Tolkein, anti-industrialization point of comparison, I think--he and Hulme were contemporaries, after all, and served in the same war), condescends and visits the man walking (Hulme? a poet? mankind?), and shows that He is everywhere--in the stars, the town's citizenry, the growth of crops and the rest of the verdure.  Put another way: God is everywhere, and we are welcome to pass through and observe, as He observes us.  But why only the nod?

Going back to the previous poem, is the nod on this evening stroll any less respectful or complete than the well-intended though menial tribute of the rose, song, or poem?  Maybe this is all the more respectful for the practical realization that any more praise is no more complete--just frilly, as though the prayer were more for the garnered respect of other poets and men, not God.

While readily apparent in the first poem, what significance there is and so easy to recognize for its exotic words, so here is the title so easy to overlook for its blatant mundanity, but a title--at least in the hands of the skilled, or attentive, at least--is never a throwaway, and here, it is the link to the overall theme of beauty unattainable.

Such is the call of any title, and the essence that elevates it from label, which is so often the case for novels.  A poem's title, and any artistic piece's title, should be a matting and frame (consider a worn wooden frame versus a lavish gilt one, and what their careful selection can do to the artwork within), indicating significance of colors, direction of eye, intended value, audience, etcetera.  But what beauty might this frame add to the poem?  "Autumn."  I think it taps into the nostalgia of the reader, and the general experience most of the Northern hemisphere has with warmth against the chill of coming winter.  More than that, well, how beautiful is a crystal clear autumn night with a great big harvest moon hanging low?

Into the next poem, "Above the Dock," it is this moon, the oculus of God, that carries the torch, though it might be said that the torch is dropped.

There are two ways to look at this entry, and I think they go hand in hand.  One is the continued ubiquity of deity, and second is the simple beauty of the image presented.  This is another poem written just after the very invention of the new poetic movement and by its inventor after all.  Looking at this image and its beauty, it persists in the melancholy of the previous two ("Mana Aboda" is obviously melancholy, but the blue of the second rests in the season, autumn--always at least a little mournful, especially at night).  The moon is "tangled," and once looked "so far away."  If the moon is again our connection to Heaven, then we lose the benevolence of the ruddy-faced farmer.  Now He is far.  And when we realize that it isn't the moon at all--God, or his eye--it's just a balloon, which distances Him even farther from us than he was.  Notice also that there are no stars this night; they've retreated with their moon, and the stars are a device Hulme uses as frequently and pointedly.  These stars, however, make their renewed appearance in the fourth poem, "The Embankment," at least by influence, if not in personal appearance.  Here we also get a second mention of the impotence of poetry.

Scanning this poem, there appear a string of allusions and references.  An "embankment" is, most simply, a wall of earth; a "fantasia" is not typically used to represent fantasy, but is a free-from musical composition (kind of like Hulme's own free-verse poetry); the literal music of the fantasia goes with the fiddles' and their finesse, though distant they are, in line 1, and no more than a lost glamor in line 2; lines 3 and 4 indicate that futility of poetry--or "poesy," an old way of saying poetry--and itself a potential symbol for the opulence mentioned in 1; and lines 5-8 are a prayer where once again we get the great, unfortunate distance between God and the narrator, and this with the addition of a nice little bit of negative connotation in "star-eaten blanket," like the stars are no more than noisome moths at the woolens.

This poem seems a lot bigger to me than the previous three.  Is it imagistic?  Yes.  The flashes of old riches and earthly comfort are visual and even audible; the prayer has a strong tactile quality to it; the emotion--a sixth sense--is stronger here than in any of the others; and the embankment itself, like an earthy sofa for the homeless--spiritually or literally homeless--against which they may rest their backs, wrapped in a natty blanket.  Such a blanket, though, is mere fantasy for this fallen gentleman.  He's lost everything, God is too far away--either because that is the nature of this capricious God, or because the man has done something to sacrifice his favor--as is the false poetics of his former life, and there is no blanket.  In this desperate moment he prays, but without hope.

So what of beauty?  I have to confess a personal preference here: this is my favorite of all of Hulme's poem.  It is also his most famous (if famous can describe any of his works).  There's a close second in "Town Sky-Line," below, though it lacks the emotional potency of "The Embankment."  What it does have is a distinct dark beauty of language; it is despair and ugliness portrayed elegantly, beautifully, which only heightens the emotion of the solitude and emptiness the man feels.

Makes me wonder what he did or what happened to him.  Makes me wonder about the possibility of autobiography.  It sounds confessional--almost.

Before we move on, look back at the progression so far:

  1. an abstract look at deity and her disappointment--with unverifiable cause--and the futility of poetry;
  2. it is night, cold, and there is God, present if unreachable;
  3. night lingers, God has departed;
  4. the thrilling nightlife has completed its course and left a casualty, who prays for the simplest comfort but is left without.
The title of the fifth appears to offer reprieve: "conversion," the word, indicates a change from one state to another.  Has the gentleman--and is this the same man from the preceding two poems? --turned his life around?  Have prayers been answered?  Is God not so far after all--drawn near by the man, or the man having drawn himself nearer God?  "Conversion" is not, I think, a return to day and a departure to another land where, perhaps, the grass is greener or the flowers more lovely.  Given the context from the rest of the suite, I believe this is a dream, which does not remove the dreamer from his physical location and predicament, except for the temporary relief sleep might offer.

This fifth contribution returns us to the abstraction of the first, and, as I mentioned before, is the foil for the mentioned theme from the preface.  But beauty here has an almost malevolent presence.  Beauty doesn't need the encased protection and offered-immortality of poets' words; beauty, loveliness, is her own eunuch--her own protector.  The narrator--the man, Hulme, all of us, whoever--walks into this dream cheerfully, expecting relief, perhaps.  And every visual cue indicates such should be the case, but the beauty is suffocating and sweeps him away, wrapping him up bodily, just his little eyes peeking out, to the final river.  While I believe that the "peeping Turk" is just for the image of it, and the Bosphorous because it's right there in Turkey, the "final river" is the important metaphor, as there are two eternal destination, each with its own series of rivers, four a piece in fact: Paradise and Hell.

I expect at this point the man awakes, but it's not mentioned.  The end is left open.  I wonder if beauty is taking her revenge on the poet for such shoddy adulation.  Here the poet literally steps into--invades--the beautiful, rather than just attempting to transcribe it, and it is indeed a trespass.  He's not permitted, and she defends herself from his uncleanness.  Note the return of the explicit female that's been missing since "Mana Aboda," and after her attack, like an immune system, the man is carried away, ignominious as the Joseph he is.  (But come on!  Is it that insulting to be only a Joseph!?)

And that's it.  "The Collected Poetical Works of T.E. Hulme."  

So, uh, therefore what?  Is there a point?  A lesson?  Or, being a collection of imagist poetry, is it just something pretty to look and think about?  

A final thought:  Hulme is not only a master technician, but an artist.  Artists tend to have statements, or a font from which they draw the necessary emotion and passion to drive their work.  These poems are indeed emotionally driven, but I don't know enough about Hulme to make any conclusion about where the emotions draw from.  I want to say this series is autobiographical, but I can't.  Maybe instead I see myself in that man of these poems who seeks God and beauty, and is left--worst case scenario--lost in a river or cold against the embankment (interesting: in "Conversion," there is a wrapping, a blanket of sorts, while in "The Embankment" it's denied him).  I certainly fall short.  I fail over and over again, and it even seems that the very beauty I seek to explore and convey in my own writing is indeed out to get me.  She is the source and object of my inspiration, and I only ever catch glimpses of her from either end--source or result.  But this, for me, is a thing separate from seeking God; while here, for Hulme, they appear to be the same, or at least closely connected.  My problem with Hulme is that by all appearance, he let frustration and hopelessness win out.  He stopped writing poetry long before his death.

Or did he just stop while he was ahead?

***

The Treasure Hunt

Tracking down Hulme has been a treasure hunt.  It started five and a half years ago with a research project assigned to my students.  One group took Hulme.  I had only two of his pieces at that point, "Image" and "The Embankment," but knew nothing else about him--nothing.  The group worked diligently but found little, only a few more pieces that only further sparked my curiosity.  For the most part, the following years were too busy to do much more than enjoy what I did have.  The last couple months, however, have seen an increase of fervor for the hunt, and it's been exciting--from "digging up" a few more pieces online, to taking my son into the bowels of the philosophy section of the BYU library to find Hulme's Collected Writings.  There's something about this quality of the unknown, the discovered, and the required efforts and adventure that make all of it--the man, his life, his art--that much more attractive.  Maybe he's really not as great as I think he is, and that's why he's so greatly unrecognized, and maybe I'll come back to all this in a few years and wonder why I was so smitten.  Maybe it was just the thrill of the hunt.

Who cares?  I've loved every minute.  His words are still electric and inspiring.  And that's the point, I think.

***

A couple additional pieces (special thanks to Sarah C., who found these HERE (scroll all the way to the bottom of the preview and get the final few poems I didn’t know even existed—exciting!) and relayed the message):

Consider the following as a foil to “Image:”


[untitled]
The flounced edge of a skirt
            recoiling like waves off a cliff.

And one more:

Town Sky-Line
On a summer day, in Town,
Where chimneys fret the cumuli,
Flora passing in disdain
Lifts her flounced blue gown, the sky.
So I see her white cloud petticoat,
Clear Valenciennes, meshed by twisted cowls,
Rent by tall chimneys, torn lace, frayed and fissured.

***

* I wish I had all these materials--the hard-to-find and expensive collections--just with me (though that would sacrifice the adventure of tracking them down).  Alas time and money are temporarily insurmountable obstacles.  There are  available sources which could give me all the information I need—and which I really want—to write a much more complete portrait of this artist—maybe my favorite artist—than anything I’m managing here.  Unfortunately, copyright laws prohibit a full disclosure of his “Selected Writings” by Google Books, and his complete writings are only available by $200 payment or regular patronage to BYU’s Harold B. Lee Library, twenty minutes away.  I am not dissatisfied, but it’s difficult sometimes to moderate my impatience for the information and materials I really want.  Selfish, huh?

***

Playlists:

Mozart and Chopin -- 
(perhaps Mozart's "Requiem" doesn't fit the effortless/dedicated dichotomy)



Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones

[Bach and Debussy]


Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones

By the way, Hulme and the other imagists believed that the cadence of poetry should not be like the measured time of a metronome or a duple versus a triple meter, but follow the cadence of a musical phrase.  Put more simply, the meter should follow the singer or the violin, not the rhythm section or, for you steel drummers, the engine room.  Ballet, not steam engine maintenance.  In their words: Pound, “Compose in the sequence of the musical phrase, not in the sequence of the metaphor;” Hulme (who appears even to mock those of the carefully measured meter in metric), “It is a delicate and difficult art, that of evoking an image, of fitting the rhythm to the idea, and one is tempted to fall back into the comforting and easy arms of the old, regular metre, which takes away all the trouble for us.”

*

Special thanks to James and Devin (here) who helped me work out a couple of especially baffling passages.

Minggu, 28 November 2010

Sunday Poetry II -- TREES, an Arboretum of Them

My intent is not to make each week thematic.  Last week holiday stuff, this week trees, next week....  I don't know yet.  Most likely it will turn out that way--thematic--contrary to my intentions--because my fingers and (if this makes any sense at all) my brain have a mind of their own.  (See?  Make any sense?)

Anyway, I was scanning my bookshelves for potential sources for poetry entries and saw the book that I will eventually describe and also show later.  After seeing it and remembering what's in it (it's been a while since I read it), I followed myself backward through my mind along the path that you, as your read, will take, not backward, but--yeah--forward.  Got it?  Totally lost?  Sound like total bunk?  Who cares.  You've read The Giving Tree, right?

That's good enough.

So, trees.  What about them, aside that since moving to Utah, after having grown up in Ohio, then Michigan, then back to Utah, where, by the way, there aren't trees, except in the mountains where you only go a couple times a year when you've got time or gas money or the roads aren't under twenty-five feet of snow, I've realized trees are a major part of my personal identity.  This trait came into particularly sharp focus my first year teaching at the Saginaw Arts and Sciences Academy when the other H.S. English teacher and I took the kids on the traditional writers' retreat to Higgins Lake.  Trees, glorious trees, were everywhere, and more than just me, seemed to consume the greater part of nearly everyone's writing.  (I will not condemn you to reading any of mine.)

And how apt they are for verse and metaphor!  We're all familiar, though likely you won't have read the piece in its entirety or been familiar with its poet:

I think that I shall never see
A poem lovely as a tree.
A tree whose hungry mouth is prest
Against the earth's sweet flowing breast;
A tree that looks at God all day,
And lifts her leafy arms to pray;
A tree that may in summer wear
A nest of robins in her hair;
Upon whose bosom snow has lain;
Who intimately lives with rain.
Poems are made by fools like me,
But only God can make a tree.
"TREES," by Joyce Kilmer

a bonsai -- metonymy of metonymies
Poetry, however, and contrary to the opinion of most, doesn't need to swing merrily from its iambs or heroic (or nearly so) couplets.  A poem, I feel very safe saying, and despite the master, Coleridge's, claim that poetry is "the best words in the best order," doesn't even need to dwell within the confines of words, as "Trees," though it doesn't exemplify, yet claims; what it does need is, at least, an image (at right):

(By the way, to those of you who've read Life of Pi, which I've mentioned here before, don't lines 5 and 6 of Kilmer's poem remind you of the moment on the carnivorous island when Pi finds the pathetic little tree apart from the forest?  Even better, the opening sentence even sounds like Kilmer!

"I know I will never know a joy so vast as I experienced when I entered that tree's dappled, shimmering shade and heard the dry, crisp sound of the wind rustling its leaves.  The tree was not as large or as tall as the ones inland, and for being on the wrong side of the ridge, more exposed to the elements, it was a little scraggly and not so uniformly developed as its mates.  But it was a tree, and a tree is a blessedly good thing to behold when you've been lost at sea for a long, long time.  I sang that tree's glory, its solid, unhurried purity, its slow beauty.  Oh, that I could be like it, rooted to the ground but with my every hand raised up to God in praise!  I wept.")

Poetry, I think, is an encapsulation of a little piece of the world.  Not like a good fiction is.  Good fiction, to me, is more like a tremendous landscape, capturing the world--or a large piece of it--all at once and in glorious and meticulous organization; poetry is the metonymy of that landscape, a single detail that somehow speaks for the whole.  Trees do this well.

David Byrne (yes, the same David Byrne as the man from The Talking Heads) wrote--or drew--a book, published by, yes, McSweeney's, and quite a lovely bit of poetry it is, and exemplifying, and certainly beyond Coleridge's quotation's words' initial intentions, because whoever said that the words had to be in any kind of prescribed left-to-right or top-to-bottom orientation, or even one following the next?

the whole book
By calling to mind the forms of trees (and other familiar forms) and using them to add visual cue to seemingly random groupings of words, he causes the reader/viewer to create associations (which is what any art and artist, however simple or complex, attempt and attest to do) previously unexplored or explored via new routes and under new illumination.  Byrne himself, in his intro, "Why?" says in the final paragraph: "So, here I am pencil in hand, poking around in the dark--wait, is it a pencil or a flashlight? ...that's it!  The pencil is a flashlight, and it roughly illuminates a tiny part of the above 'intelligence.'  Maybe just enough to get it all wrong, but the puzzle pieces are us--we can recognize familiar pieces of ourselves, and so they are scary, fascinating and lovable."

I can't show you the whole book, save from without the confines of its cover, like I could if we were sitting in a classroom.  However, I can show you the cover, and I can show you a couple things that are behind it.  If this pique your interest, buy the book.  You won't be sorry.  (...except that maybe you won't have any money left!  Holy crap!  I didn't know it wasn't available anymore except for, like, a million dollars!  Maybe I'll have to sell mine....  Any takers?)

Here are four "poems" or trees, photographed from my copy of Arboretum (and not very easy to read--sorry).  While examining, thing about an actual tree: the roots and the branches word in a sort of tandem cause and effect--the roots cause the growth of the limbs and leaves, which in turn feed the growth and nourishment of the roots.  Locate items in mirrored position above and below and ask how they might feed, engender, or cause the growth of (or, conversely, the death of) the other.





***

Finally, and in an epilogue of sorts, Byrne's trees remind me of a sort of metaphorically treeish version of  Everything that Rises (another big recommendation for this post), the book and concept themselves as trees, from Lawrence Weschler, plus all the additional convergences, also at McSweeneys, as a type of verbal reckoning of Byrne's trees, and one in particular, whose image is here, with its two corresponding links (enjoy):



***


Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones